For fans of Martin, the beloved 90s sitcom, Carl Anthony Payne’s character “Cole Brown” was a lovable but dim-witted friend who was always good for a laugh. His on-screen chemistry with Martin Lawrence made for countless memorable moments. But behind the scenes, things weren’t always so smooth. Payne and Lawrence’s off-screen relationship was far more complicated, filled with tension and a feud that lasted for decades.
Early Career Success for Carl Anthony Payne and Martin Lawrence
Carl Anthony Payne’s Rise to Fame
Carl Anthony Payne’s career began in the mid-1980s with a role on The Cosby Show as Walter “Cockroach” Bradley, where he was introduced to many as the fun and energetic friend of Theo Huxtable. This role showcased Payne’s comedic timing, and soon he was working steadily, making appearances in shows like Hull High and Quantum Leap.
It wasn’t until 1992 that Payne landed the role of “Cole Brown” on Martin, the show that would define his career. Martin was a cultural phenomenon, with Payne playing the role of Lawrence’s goofy sidekick, adding another layer of humor to the show’s dynamic.
Even though Payne’s role in Martin became his most iconic, he continued to act after the show’s end, with credits in shows like Jack & Jill, Young Dylan, and 5th Ward.
Martin Lawrence’s Meteoric Rise
Martin Lawrence, the leading star of Martin, was no stranger to fame by the time the show aired in 1992. He had already made a name for himself as a comedian on Def Comedy Jam, where his raw and brash comedic style captured the attention of many. His transition from stand-up to acting seemed natural, with his charisma and humor translating effortlessly to television.
In Martin, he played the character of Martin Payne, a loud and opinionated DJ-turned-talk-show host, and it quickly became one of the most successful sitcoms of the 90s. The show propelled Lawrence into superstardom, leading to major roles in movies like Bad Boys, Blue Streak, and Big Momma’s House. By the mid-90s, Lawrence was a household name in both television and film.
The Beef: How It All Started
Despite their on-screen chemistry, rumors began swirling about tension between Carl Anthony Payne and Martin Lawrence during the show’s run. While most of the attention at the time was on the very public feud between Lawrence and Tisha Campbell, Payne’s issues with Lawrence went largely unnoticed until much later.
In an interview, Carl Payne shed light on the situation, admitting that things started off fine between him and Lawrence. However, as the seasons progressed, the dynamic began to shift. Payne described many “tense days” on set, pointing out that Lawrence seemed to have personal demons he was battling, which made him difficult to work with.
“We had a lot of tense days on the set… I live by a certain code of ethics. I’m from Harlem, you know how we do,” Payne shared in an interview. “Yeah, we had issues, but I think he [Martin] had issues with himself really. I don’t think he was in a good place at that time”.
Payne went on to say that while he tried to keep things professional, the mistreatment eventually crossed a line. He emphasized that while they were like family, families fight, and for a while, the set became an uncomfortable place to work.
“Once you cross the line and you come at me in a way that I can’t sleep at night or feel like you’re threatening me, then it’s a different story,” Payne added.
Tisha Campbell’s Lawsuit and Its Impact
While Payne’s beef with Lawrence simmered under the radar, the relationship between Lawrence and Tisha Campbell exploded into the public eye. Campbell, who played Gina Waters, Martin’s girlfriend on the show, filed a lawsuit against Lawrence during the show’s final season, accusing him of sexual harassment and inappropriate behavior on set.
The lawsuit shook the cast and crew, causing a rift between Campbell and Lawrence that, for a time, seemed irreparable. Campbell alleged that Lawrence had physically and emotionally abused her through harassment, battery, and violent threats. While Lawrence denied these allegations, the lawsuit cast a shadow over the final season of Martin. Campbell refused to film scenes with Lawrence, and the show ended shortly after the lawsuit was filed.
For many fans, the sudden end of Martin was a shock. Lawrence later claimed that it was simply time for the show to end, but the controversies and tension on set told a different story.
Reconciliation After Tommy Ford’s Passing
For years, Payne and Lawrence went without speaking. Their feud remained largely unresolved until tragedy struck in 2016 with the death of their fellow Martin co-star, Tommy Ford, who played Tommy Strawn on the show. Ford’s passing became the catalyst for reconciliation between the two former co-stars.
At Ford’s funeral, Payne and Lawrence reconnected. Payne later reflected on the moment, expressing how time and personal growth helped mend their relationship.
“I think people grow. At the end of the day, the things you may have been mad about at 20-something… For me, I was in a whole other space,” Payne said in an interview.
It was clear that both men had matured over the years, and the pain of their feud no longer held the same weight. Lawrence, who had also grown and moved past his own personal struggles, was open to mending fences. By the end of their reconciliation, Payne and Lawrence were able to reflect on their shared history with less animosity, realizing that their younger selves may have been too caught up in the heat of the moment.
Despite the drama that unfolded off-screen, Martin remains one of the most iconic sitcoms of the 90s, loved by fans for its humor and memorable characters. Even as the cast faced challenges behind the scenes, they managed to create something that continues to resonate with audiences today.
Leave a comment and share your thoughts on Martin Lawrence not only treating Tisha Campbell horribly on the set of Martin, but him also bullying Carl Anthony Payne to the point where he had beef with him too.
